UNCIVILIZED COW NATIONALISM VERSUS CIVILIZED GOAT NATIONALISM

Theory of Justice is a classical piece written by John Rawls in the twentieth century which paved way for opening a room for discussion on socio-political-economic or cultural rights of various categories under this broad category of Justice. Justice can be in any form but an individual should not fail to get justice for any reason or for any identity. A civilized human being would never refuse to any protest ideologies in order to expose their crushed identities in the public sphere except for extreme radical Islamic or Hindutva ideologies which are a dangerous thought process for the human existence with the fear of Islama or Hindutva phobia.

I may raise a doubt about whether some societies or religious faiths do know the practice of civilized behavior in public sphere at all? I am asking this question myself whether I really know the meaning of civilization being part and parcel of this Indian subcontinent. What is my personal experience with Indians or Hindus for the past 39 years in this subcontinent? Does Hindus know the meaning of art of living without lies or unethical life? Can Indians live without psychological or physical violence or social hierarchies that have been sponsored by Hindu religious scriptures which ruined their thought process? When can we expect an Indian speaking truth at least in few minutes? Can Indian speak truth at all in his or her life time? Can Indian pass a single minute without lying?

Since I do not have any personal experience with Muslims I can’t say about their daily life but I can say about Hindus hundred percentage due to my birth in particular communities such as a hegemonic Pooja-Yadav community and marginalized Madiga community to which my parents belongs. Pooja Yadavas are one of the ruling kingdoms of this Indian subcontinent. Yadavas had ruled Indians for more than six thousand years. We have still got Mysore Kingdom of Yadav-Vadayaars. We are still ruling entire north Indian states as well as few south Indian metropolitan cities such as Secunderabad. So I had born in this powerful Pooja- Yadav community in India. And Yadavas are the ruling communities of other countries within Asia or Pacific region such as Nepal or Fiji or Bali or wherever Hindus live Yadavas rule them. The recent elections in Bihar has clearly witnessed in the state of Bihar that Yadav’s party under the leadership of Lalu Prasad Yadav had defeated Hindu’s party Bharatiya Janata Party in the elections. It is not only Bihar but also 16 states in north or west or eastern states are controlling by Yadav community. We are the rulers of Uttar Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh states. We are the predominant community of entire north India without doubt. This is my social back ground to which my half identity goes whereas my another identity is the identity of Jambava who ruled this country according to Hindu puranas so I belonged to two powerful communities but Yadav’s are the most powerful and hegemonic community which ruled Indians for more than six thousand years without any challenge from the non-Yadav communities in the Indian subcontinent. Hence, I knew the every moment of Hindu communities rather than Christians or Muslims or Sikhs. Perhaps I can guess that there won’t be greater differences between Hindus and non-Hindus in terms of unethical behaviors or violent practices in this subcontinent. Eminent Social Scientists with human face Gurram Jashuva Madiga-Yadav and Professor Kancha Ilaiah Yadav who (both had) converted to Christianity argued that one can derive realities by using personal experiences in a society like India where truth has been buried from the six thousands year in the name of Hindu culture and tradition. Unfortunately there is not even a single resistance voice from the victims of Hindu fundamentalism in this subcontinent. My Yadav Mother SUGUNA YADAV says one should bring out buried histories of resistance cultures or ideologies into public sphere in order to create an egalitarian society where nobody can fear of eating beef or dog or any animal or bird without superimposition like white western Christian societies where everyone exercise their freedom of choice or individuality without interference of religion or state or culture or tradition.

But my Brazil and Australian education has changed my mind set from supporting lies to supporting truth. I find that white western Christians in Brazil or Australia are very honest and hard working with strong ethical back ground whereas Asians are most lie based people with uncivilized thoughts and actions. When I stay in Sydney I saw cricket match between India and Australia but white western Australians never behave like India’s behave with uncivilized behavior or vulgar language. Australians were behaved very decently with descent behavior. But if anyone observes Indian behavior during the cricket between Indians and non-Indians we can say Indians are most uneducated people in the world. We feel to teach Indians how to behave decently in public sphere or during the cricket match. I never saw such ugly behavior like Indians in Brazil or Australia at the time of cricket. Brazilians are named for foot ball but they never behave such an uncivilized manner that Indians behave during the time of cricket match.

Now I want to raise a question about what is the role of Indian academic institutions from the Elementary School to University in order to make Indians in such an ugly condition that Indians behave with ugly behavior without any decency. Why Indian Hindu education system did have failed to train Indians with civilized thoughts or actions in public sphere? Why did Indian’s behave in a way that nobody can appreciate except Hindus in India? Why Indian academic system does has failed to train Indians in relation to honest or hard work without barbarian thoughts and actions. Cricket nationalism in India is a fake nationalism to unite all the pseudo under the umbrella of Hindu identity. When would Indians learn to behave like civilized white western Christians at home or public sphere? When would Indians can learn to see sports is sports without bringing BHARAT MATA KI JAI or another fake nationalisms in the name of VANDEMATARAM? When would Indian’s learn sports spirit or knowledge spirit?  Hindus say that they had universities like Takshashila or Nalanda universities 2000 years ago but why did they failed to discover any subject or item or any without depending on white western Christian societies for developing Indian society?  Indians claim of 0 (zero) is not discovered by Indians at all if we observe the mental condition of Indians. They do not process or acquire intellectual ship or they do not have any critical thinking process to find or discover any theory. As per my experience of Indians I can assume that no Indian can meet the international standard in regard to thought process or behavior to be good human beings. Indians does not have history of good human beings if we read their uncivilized cultural and traditional behaviours. Indians are the most hypocrites people in the world. I never seen such kind of hypocrites in my life time.

When would Indian Hindus realize their inferior knowledge system or inferior human mind in order to compete with white western Christian mind? When would Indian’s behave with civilized thoughts in public sphere? When would they learn to be civilized in the world? When would Indian’s learn the meaning of honesty or knowledge or humanity or progressive ideas without assassinating the character of white western Christians through the non-meritorious Indian cinema in the name of Indian culture and tradition? When would India’s learn the spirit of sports without jealousy or inferior complexities or when would Indian’s support modernity or human rights of individuals without imposing their so-called culture or tradition on progressive minds.

Therefore, I can clearly define Indian ideology from my personal experience with Indian castes that Indian means anti-scientific, anti-progressive thoughts, anti-rationality, anti-humanity, anti-love, anti-care, anti-hospitality, anti-merit, anti-equality-liberty-freedom-fraternity, anti-patience, anti-tolerance, anti-application of reason, anti-human but cow…so cow nationalism is very dangerous to the progressive ideas to establish modern state in India.

Let us fight against religious intolerance in the name of Hindu culture and tradition…where there is creative ideas flourish these lie based religious fundamentalism will be disappeared so let us create modern knowledge to bury the religious fundamentalism in the name of cow.

AMBEDKAR, GANDHI AND NEHRU

Dr B R Ambedkar is an eminent Social Scientist i.e. Economist, Political thinker, Sociologist and Advocate with a strong western knowledge back ground. His western studies at the Christian Universities Colombia University in the United States of America and London School of Economics at the Great Britain have enabled him to architect the Constitution of India with the support of other drafting committee members. His Buddhist or any other indigenous knowledge had never helped him to get any modern knowledge i.e. knowledge of human rights. By the time Ambedkar went to Colombia University or LSE they are filled with many eminent Social Scientists who changed the thought process of him. In fact, there is a huge difference between Ambedkar, Gandhi and Nehru who went to study abroad. If Ambedkar went to study the world prestigious knowledge centers i.e. Colombia University and London School of Economics then Gandhi and Nehru went to study at the non-knowledge centers in South Africa or London. Indeed Gandhi or Nehru never focuses on intellectual field because they went to study with their own personal money to enjoy life in abroad unlike Dr B R Ambedkar who went with merit scholarship which led his life to focus on creating progressive knowledge. His volumes are witness for the academic scholarship he created in the aspects of history, polity, society, culture, Scriptures, religion, constitution etc unlike Gandhi’s or Nehru’s non-serious works which became icons for non-serious academic community of India. Nehru’s The Discovery of India or Gandhi’s My Experience with Truth are nowhere standing in the intellectual arena unlike Ambedkar’s classical pieces running into tens of thousands of pages. Indeed Gandhi and Nehru are intellectually inferiors than Dr B R Ambedkar who is not only a dedicated Social Scientist but also a champion of human rights of people in India. His human rights approach is not only benefited lower sections of the Hindu society but for entire people of the society. If Gandhi’s or Nehru’s National Movement had benefited only to the Brahmins politically, economically, culturally, religiously, educationally then the efforts of Ambedkar had benefited entire Indians. But unfortunately he had forgotten to guide his people in intellectual arena. His guidance of getting political power has ruined the spirit of knowledge creation by his own Mahar/Mala communities. They are focusing on earning money through various back doors like their fellow Hindus. Therefore, there is no difference between Gandhi or Nehru or Ambedkar to lead their followers to earn money through various unethical ways. If anybody observes Hindus or Mahars/Malas in terms of corruption lies, unethical activities or uncivilized thoughts or practices then you can’t find difference between them. Both groups are competing for power, power in many ways. If Hindus use their hereditary hierarchies to ruin the spirit of knowledge creation then Untouchable communities are using caste as a weapon to capture power. Both are using caste card to capture power. Power is depending on the minority or majority to dominate each other. Gandhi and Nehru thought Hindus to capture power at the cost of egalitarian principals of Theory of Justice (John Rawls) without creating any progressive knowledge. The same way Dr B R Ambedkar had guided his community but with converting to non- Hindu believes. He guided his community people politically but he had failed to guide them intellectually. Therefore, his community people have become intellectually inferiors in the knowledge creation by competing with their fellow Hindus.

If the most persecuted Jewish community of Germany had focused on knowledge creation through which they have attracted entire world to change their social status then the world most persecuted Untouchable or African community of India-Asia/Africa had become manipulators by ignoring the value of knowledge creation. With my personal experience I understood that people who captured knowledge are becoming world leaders in every aspect like the white western Christian society than the people who are interested in lies, unethical practices, dishonest, corruption like Asians and Africans are becoming agents of age old practices of uncivilized thoughts and actions.

With the personal experience I got in Brazil and Australia when I went to study International Graduate Course in History, Heritage, Memory at the Federal University of Bahia, Brazil or Master of Human Rights at the University of Sydney in Australia with the merit scholarships everyone from those countries used to say that ‘oh you are a smart student’ unlike your fellow Indians. Here smart student means intellect academically. But very few smart students are the people who read, write, understand and analyze any society or culture or tradition to say people that what is right and wrong or what is good and bad even though people don’t like their words or actions. Their actions or thoughts are progressive and creative unlike people who are going to abroad for earning millions of dolors in the name of education

Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi or Nehru is such kind of people who went to South Africa or London for their studies with their own block money unlike Dr B R Ambedkar. In fact Gandhi was a Son of Chief Minister of his region whereas Nehru was a Son of richest person unlike Ambedkar whose father was an employee of the British Raj. Gandhi’s and Nehru’s richness had paved way for getting political power by using unethical movements unlike the Human Rights of Dr B R Ambedkar. Ambedkar was, in fact, a strong supporter of self-respect, dignity, perhaps no idea about his standpoint on individual identity. He spoke for group identity i.e. identity of Untouchables in India like Gandhi’s battle for Touchable Indians to transform power from egalitarian British to Indian hegemonic communities. Of course British Raj is the main enemy of sub-subaltern sections who established the hegemony of Top of the twice borne communities in the Indian society at the cost of marginalized sections unlike white western Christian missionaries who came to abolish Indian way of uncivilized practices such as practice of Untouchability or infant deaths. There is a conflict of differences of British rulers in India and British missionaries. If British rulers install the hegemony of dominant castes in India then the British missionaries had started educating Brahmin women and lower caste people. So human rights students should pose a question of what is the value of individuality in the context of Asia in general or India in particular when the religious fundamental identities (non-Christian faiths in Asia or Africa) are crushing the individual rights of people.

Let us fight for individual rights or freedom to advance the egalitarian principals of equality, liberty, freedom and fraternity.

HELL: THY NAME IS INDIAN UNIVERSITIES

I have been witnessing a vulgar behavior of Ph.D. student of Kannada Literature in the Dravidian University since more than one year. He is from the state of Karnataka. He belonged to some intellectually inferior non-meritorious backward-low caste community which is falling under the category of Open Backward Class (OBC) Reservation. He is almost 30 years old non-meritorious PhD student with a tongue of lies, manipulations and vulgar behavior with violent nature in the name of BHARAT MATA KI JAI. This non-meritorious student is doing his PhD under the guidance of another intellectually inferior reservation holder. As his guide does not know what is research this boy has developed the hatredness against modern principals of self-respect, dignity, individuality, body and self by crushing the human values of love, care, affection, humanity etc. I have seen violent behavior of this violent PhD student while beating small animals with big stones. I have seen this OBC student with alcohol and abusive tongue in the company of his Kannada Brahmin PhD student friend.

As I had been to Brazil and Australia for my studies in Human Rights courses it has been a very peculiar to see such kind of behavior in him in particular and common in most of Indians. His behavior is not first or lost but it’s my personal experience of such kind of ugly behavior of Kannada student.  Whenever there is a cricket match is going on between India and non-India then this man comes and uses his tongue very vulgarly against the non-Indian women. Indeed he uses same vulgar language against our own Indian mother or sister. But for these anti-human rights Hindu fundamental using vulgar language against non-Indians is a national. If whoever human rights people like me oppose such kind of vulgar behavior then these non-meritorious PhD students or teachers come into his risk in the name of INDIAN. This 30 years non-meritorious reservation holder or his intellectually inferior friends knows only drinking alcohol or drugs or teasing girls or passing comments on girls or women or using un-parliamentary language against white western societies. Very interesting thing is he is not even fit for academics but how come he passes his Masters or how come he is doing PhD without knowing the meaning of RESEARCH. I have observed most of these reservation holders backed by agricultural castes, trading castes, vernacular speaking Brahmins are most non-meritorious students like their intellectually inferior teachers or guides.

These intellectually inferior students belonged to various Indian castes are most-unproductive, most violent, uncivilized and most lazy people on the university campuses like their teachers who spend their time for chit chat or personal matters from morning 10 am to evening 5pm. They define Indian identity from their Hindu religious point of view by crushing the identities of many i.e gender, caste, region, linguistic, religion etc. If any foreign degree holder tries to explain what is right and wrong and good and bad in academics or responsibilities of students or teachers then they use their tongue for ugly things like I will fuck your mother or sister…in the name of BHARAT MATA KI JAI… They are most dangerous to their own women because these intellectually inferior alcoholic PhD students rape their own women and give slogans against non-Indian women. Their education is not teaching morals indeed ugly behavior with the women or intellectuals. I do know the vulgar behavior of Indian mindset to prevent advancement of society from the ugly thoughts of their everyday life mostly pre-determined by their religious mind set.

Generally universities suppose to create progressive students, scholars and intellectuals but unfortunately these Indian universities are producing thieves and liars unlike its western scholars who hold truth and hard work by creating progressive knowledge throughout their life.

There is no much difference between Vemula Rohit-an OBC PhD student from the University of Hyderabad and this ugly PhD student from the Dravidian University in terms of practicing violent or lie based life without knowing the value of good human being or without knowing the value of freedom of expression or freedom of speech. Universities are running with the money of common man but unfortunately these intellectually inferior students and teachers are ruining academic spirit by indulging into various unethical aspects of life

Finally Indian universities are hell for progressive intellectuals and humanists 

MODERNITY UNDER THREAT

We are in an authoritarian state where there is no freedom of speech or freedom of expression. I am really shocked by the way in which eminent Professor Nivedita Menon is being booked by the State in the name of Sedition. How to understand this fascist Hindutva state when uneducated politicians are ruling unlawfully with the full pledged support of uneducated masses, bureaucrats, judiciary and hegemonic ideas by crushing the progressive voices in the present scenario of twenty first century India? Why is the majority academic community of India (majority of Indian academic community is non-meritorious in the intellectual domain with few exceptional cases of individuals or centers such as CSDS, CSSS, CSCS and with few JNU) is so silent and what made these intellectually inferior academic community is silent when the intellectually superior scholars are being targeted by fascist Hindu government at the center in the name of sedition? How to understand intellectually inferior subaltern (teachers belonged to agrarian castes, trading castes, tribal communities and Kshatriya castes and Indian languages speaking Brahmins) castes and sub-subaltern castes (so-called Ambedkar followers in the academic institutions) who are intellectually inferior are silence over the State repression against mainstream intellectuals and their progressive voices? What does Center for Women Studies do when progressive intellectuals like Professor Nivedita Menon or Human Rights Activist Teesta Setalvaad are being harassed by the hegemonic ruling groups for their unconditional support to Rights? Did Nivedia or Teesta have done any greater crime by writing classical pieces or fighting for the rights on the issues or Rights, Modernity, State Repression against intellectuals or marginalized sections? Why did intellectually inferior university teachers are lack of proper analytical skills or at least meaning of Sedition when the entire Knowledge Centers are opposing state repression against intellectuals? What is the voice of so-called university teachers or research scholars who are spending their life time for chit chat about movies, heroines, porn stars, cricket or political parties when the fascist Hindutva state is targeting intellectuals who are questioning the authoritarian nature of fascist Hindutva ruler’s? Does Nehruvian or Gandhenian ideologies who incorporated religion into politics are main reason behind all these atrocities on progressive thinkers and intellectuals? Can’t Indian masses or Indians themselves live without interference of religion or caste in their day to day life? When does academic community of Indian universities learn to know the importance of progressive ideas and thoughts for bringing an egalitarian society where human beings can live without referring to their social identity? When does progressive thoughts and ideas can be produced by Indian universities like white western Christian societies or Roman or Greek philosophers who have changed the scenario of their societies thousands of years ago? When would Indian academy react to the authoritarian nature of state in suppressing progressive minds? When would these intellectually inferior groups realize the importance of progressive ideas and thoughts? When would Ambedkar followers learn to learn to come with progressive scholars without isolating themselves from the society? When would intellectually inferior tribal communities or non-Brahmin or vernacular speaking Brahmins or Indian degree (holders) communities to come up with the side of progressive knowledge creators? When would Indian women learnt to read books and learnt to write progressive articles or essays or books to save themselves from the clutches of slavery? Now it is the responsibility of people who spoiled the spirit of knowledge creation in India to save progressive minds from the threats of aggressive Hindutva forces.