Thursday, 28 July 2016

REPRESSIVE IDEOLOGICAL APPARATUSES OF BRAHMINS


Cultural apparatuses are one of the important weapons for the repressive state apparatus in Asian society in general and Indian society in particular. As Louis Althusser identified Ideological State Apparatus as a most dangerous human threat by the hegemonic groups particularly for the lower strata society is playing by the predominant groups and ideas everywhere to rule the majority masses that are consciously unconscious about the ideological hegemony of predominant castes. The ideological state apparatus or repressive state apparatus is very visible in the everyday affairs of the Indian state. Indian Freedom struggle for freedom is one of the reproductions of the ruling castes in order to capture the political power from the most egalitarian white western British Christians to the Black Indian Hindus i.e Brahmins or non-Brahmins in south India. How the transformation of power happen from the hands of British to non-British Hindu Brahmins by suppressing the majority masses which includes fourth category Shudras(agricultural castes such as Reddy, Kamma, Velama and Kapu in south India).  First of all these foreign origin Iranian Brahmins had separated these agricultural castes into superior and inferior castes to hate among themselves by creating an ideological feeling that this Reddy is superior than that Reddy or this Kamma is superior than that Kamma. Religious apparatus or its sanction has helped Brahmins to remain power through the cultural practices. They (Brahmins) have used Hindu temples to retain their cultural supremacy over these non-Brahmin castes in order to rule them mentally. When these non-Brahmins have mentally accepted Brahmins as their Gods on earth these Brahmins started creating another slaves like Shudras to which non-Brahmins belonged i.e Untouchables so that these non-Brahmin slaves have started supporting Brahmins to carry their irrational theories and practices upon the lower caste Shudras or Untouchables without any revolt among these fourth and fifth category castes. Educational institutions such as Shanti Niketan or Gurukulam’s have helped these Brahmins to rule the minds of non-Brahmins. In the recent history of Europe even white western Christians have fallen for these Brahmins and their manipulations for Yoga or Meditation. Even so-called Prince or Princess of United Kingdom is worshipping Hindu Gods and Goddess by practicing Yoga and Meditation. It is not just these individuals from the white western Christian societies but also UNO who are worshipping or glorifying the unscientific Yoga or Meditation. UNO went on to declare the Day of Yoga internationally. It is height that these barbarian Hindu Brahmins have manipulated entire international community by drawing attention their biological relationship with the white western Christians. Indeed Britishers or Europeans are treating Brahmins as their equals in India in terms of race but unfortunately these British or Europeans are the main culprits in order to establish through various repressive state apparatus by law or act. These are the Britishers who permanently sanctioned millions of lands to the Brahmins or non-Brahmins in their ruling time. They (Britishers) had established Brahmins as the Masters of India in their post-British India. Britishers knew that as long as Brahmins rule this country inequalities will be remain so that they can come to conquer this intellectually inferior land through various means. Government running Hindu schools or Brahmins running Roman Catholic Schools is important agents of state apparatus who are carrying the legacy of Brahmins. Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi or his soldiers are important ally of Britishers who crushed the voice of lower castes or tribes particularly Untouchables or hill based tribes. Of course mainland tribals are highly sanskritized to capture the power in their tribal areas. Tribal’s had escaped from the clutches of these cultural apparatus. However they are chained by other state apparatus i.e government schools or private schools or police or armed forces in the name of Naxalism. Mainland tribal’s having become Hindus in order to escape from the haunting of Brahmins or state apparatus whereas hill based tribals have not for the sake of their belief in Son of God. Religious apparatus has very significant role in the society to remain large number of masses in the hands of few dominate castes. Hindu villages have become hell for the lives of Untouchables for their everyday life. M K Gandhi wanted to establish Hindu village in fact established in the post-British India. He (Gandhi) had fulfilled his dream of establishing Hindu-Brahmin rule over majority non-Brahmin race. Dr B R Ambedkar or his Christian converted Master Mahatma Jothibha Phule had tried to create conscious among large number of masses about the ideological apparatus of Brahmins in the oppression of Shudras or Untouchables but futile since the majority non-Brahmins are treating Brahmins as Gods on earth. At least Untouchables have realized the ideological apparatus of Brahmins everywhere in not only south India or India or south Asia or Asia but also in the white western Christian societies where Presidents and Prime Ministers or Royal families are fallen for the manipulations of Hindu Brahmins in the name of Yoga or Meditation.  However, there is no hope of equality, liberty, freedom and fraternity for the large number of Untouchables in any coming ages. Shudra slaves are learned manipulations from their Masters Brahmins whereas Untouchables yet to learn but their Masters Mahatma Jothibha Phule or Dr B R Ambedkar are cautioning them from the far distance of Heaven that doesn’t fall for these ideological apparatus of Brahmins. They are cautioning their followers to be careful about the castes of mind of Shudras or non-Brahmins who became killers of these large numbers of powerless Untouchables or Muslims. Untoucahbles are aware of ideological state apparatus of Brahmins but we don’t know when will my powerful Pooja-Yadav or Madiga communities aware of these apparatus of Brahmins. Jesus only should create this consciousness among these non-Brahmins who are not aware of their uncivilized theories and practices that are super imposed by the pious/cruel Brahmins over a period of 6000 years. Awareness is important for knowledge creation. Knowledge is power. Power leads to deconstruct the well-established ideas like Manyasri Kanshi Ram or his Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) did in the state of North India. BSP is an anti-ideological apparatus of Brahmins in India. It has created ripples in the heart of uncivilized Hindus that BSP is going to capture the power in the Center through which they (Hindus) can’t see to rule by an Untouchable. Iron lady Mayavathi is carrying the legacy of BSP Founder Kanshi Ram in order to establish a just society through the capture of political power. Indeed right wing Hindu parties are trying to eliminate this Madiga(Chamar) Party but Chamars (leather professions) are more united right from its Jambu Dwipa (Jambava is the first ruler of India or Bharat Vamsham in Puranics so it is not easy for any right wing Hindu political parties to break the ideological apparatus of Kanshi Ram among the weaker sections.21st century India needs Kanshi Ram’s ideas but not the ideas of Hindu Swaraj or Ram Rajya. Break the ideological apparatus of Brahmins to establish the ideological apparatus of Bahujan Samaj Party.

Monday, 25 July 2016

PROGRESSIVE INTELLECTUALS OR HINDU REPRESENTATIVES?


Who wanted to know the true face of Hinduism and its brutal violence against most disadvantaged groups on earth i.e. Untouchables? Who wanted to know the brutal history of Hindu philosophy which is eliminating Untouchables and Muslims with a target goal of ‘resistance free India’ from the protest ideologies of Untouchables and Muslims? What is the philosophy of so-called progressive intellectuals and their writing towards brutal violence of Hinduism on its opponents? Is it the only or soul responsibility of Professor Romila Thapar or Professor Kancha Ilaiah to respond to brutal violence of Hinduism at the cost of their life? Is it the only commitment of Professor Romila Thapar to fight against Hindu oppression at the cost of her life? Are there any books written by these leftist intellectuals against the brutl philosophy of Hinduism like Professor Aloysius works against Hindu ideology? Is it the only responsibility of Perry Anderson who published a ground breaking work THE INDIAN IDEOLOGY by analyzing entire Indian race and its intellectually inferior Hindu religious mind to suppress the most oppressed sections in the world i.e. Untouchables? What is the standpoint of Professor Partha Chatterje, Professor Ashish Nandi or other leftist Social Scientists who never dare to write on Hindu violence but going with majority religious fundamentals? Of course Professor Romila Thapar is exceptional intellectual in India who dared to write against this brutal philosophy of Hinduism and its violent followers who are eliminating Untouchables, Muslims and progressive intellectuals in the name of culture, tradition and philosophy. Why are Ambedkar followers so backward in academics? What made them to inferiors in academic discourses?

What are the cultural transgressions that are speaking by so-called progressive or left intellectuals who are carrying the legacy of Hindu religious practices at their homes? Have you ever seen a leftist intellectual death ceremony the way in which it is being celebrated in burial ground? That is why we adopt what Professor Kancha Ilaiah says about the need of focusing on post-death ceremony and its celebrations of so-called leftist intellectuals by their family members. Professor Satish Deshpande, an eminent Sociologist, from the Delhi University is an orthodox Brahmin to carry the legacy of his Brahmin tradition. I had seen while he was performing pooja for his father on the banks of Ganga in Varanasi. It is not just Professor Satish Deshpande but every leftist is the same. A progressive intellectual never allow his or her family members to do his or her death ceremonies with this uncivilized Hindu practices after their death. They could guide their family members to celebrate with specific secular manner without indulging a Brahmin priest or Hindu ceremonies while they alive but these so-called Brahmin leftist intellectuals are aware of their social status so that they never request or guide their family members to do their post-death ceremonies in a non-religious way so post-death ceremony of progressive intellectuals is matter now to come to conclusion whether they are really progressive or religious who fear in the philosophy of Brahmanical ideology. I have seen few leftist cum human rights scholars and their post-death ceremonies the way in which their family members have celebrated. For example Professor Bala Gopal whose death ceremony carried with a complete Aryan or Brahmanical way. There are many in this way.

One may ask me how come a dead body is aware of their ceremony after death. It is  a silly question because when you are not in position to convince your family members regarding this barbarian religion and its irrational theories and practices then how come you change your outside of your family. Even living legends of so-called human rights Hindu-Brahmin leftist scholars are also going in the same ship. Can these so-called leftist scholars change their practices towards non-religious practices or towards most egalitarian practices of Christian way of life? Why this leftist intellectual is are opposing conversion of masses into Christianity? What made these progressive intellectuals to oppose Christianity or English as a mother tongue of India? At the same time these leftist intellectuals are sending their kids to the Christian schools to learn only ENGLISH through which knowledge is floating. What made Professor Romila Thapar to open her voice against Hindu violence and its brutal attacks on most oppressed sections in the world i.e. Untouchables or Muslims? How come so-called progressive intellectuals from the JNU or CSDS, CSSS, CSCS, Delhi University or IITs are silence over Hindu violence? Is it because they are all belonged to same Hindu Brahmin community or someone will ask them to eat beef to prove them as progressive intellectuals.

My personal experience with CSCS-Bangalore says that they are centers with full of western degree-white skinned- polished English speaking Brahmins who hide their inner spirit but pretend to be progressive. Is it the same with CSDS or CSSS? What was the practical life of Professor Rajani Kotari who is a thought breaking political thinker in academics and founder of CSDS-celebrated social science institute in India along with CSSS? Finally what is the contribution of these celebrated social science institutions in the matters of brutal violence of Hindu religion and its unforgiveable atrocities on Untouchables and Muslims in India?

Can any intellectual dared to say being a Hindu means being inhuman in his or her theories or practices?

Friday, 22 July 2016

21st CENTURY KILLINGS OF HINDUS: LYNCHING OF UNTOUCHABLES AND MUSLIMS IN INDIA


If you are an Untouchable or Muslim in India, it is easy to lynch by the Hindu mob in the name of Cow or beef eating. Lynching of untouchable in Gujarat is the today’s news. Jesus saves the Untouchables and Muslims from the clutches of uncivilized Hindus who are killing Untouchables and Muslims mercilessly in the name of protecting cow or beef eating. Yesterday it was the time for lynching of a Muslim in Uttar Pradesh and today it is time for Untouchable in Gujarat. Where are you Jesus? When are you going to save your weaker sections in India who are being killed by Hindu mobs? Are you sleeping or watching merciless killings of Hindus upon Untouchables and Muslims?

As per my knowledge on Hindus killings of Untouchables in the name of history, heritage and culture it has a tradition of killing Untouchables for 6000 years. Indian history of violence, brutality, killings, raping, inequalities, and sexual harassment is a history of 6000 years in the matters of Untouchables but it is 70 years in the matters of Muslims. As a Historian I can attest that nowhere in the world has the longest history of Hindu violence against the Untouchables or any human being. I read the violence of Hitler upon Christians, Jewish, Sexually minorities and short people but Holocaust has very short history in the contest of Germany under the brutal leadership of Aryan-Hitler and hic uncivilized Aryan German forces. My historical mind is saying that it’s not only the era of Brahmins who started killing indigenous people with their arrival since 3000 years but Dravidians are same like their Brahmin invaders since 6000 years. So history of violence against Untouchables for ages is not new to the history of India. Let me start with Brahmin Hindu Parashuram who killed Kshatriyas mercilessly but became God for entire Hindu communities.

BARBERIAN BRAHMIN PARASHURAM: MERCILESS KILLER OF KSHATRIYAS

Who do you know the real story of this barbarian Brahmin hero-Parashuram who killed Kshtriyas mercilessly including Kshtriya women, Kshatriya babies and unborn Kshatriya babies from the womb of their Kshatriya Mothers? Why barbarians Brahmins worship Parashuram who killed Kshatriyas? What made Parashuram to kill Kshatriyaas mercilessly including Kshatriya women and Kshatriya unborn kids? Do Kshatriyas remember the way in which Brahmins eliminated Kshtriyas under the leadership of this barbarian Parashuram? What does brahmanical history says about this most violent killer of human being in their writings? Brahmins have documented the merciless killings of Parashuram in their Hindu scriptures. They have praised the way in which Parashuram had killed thousands of Kshtriyas and their wives and children including unborn children. However, these shameless Kshatriyas have accepted Brahmins as their superiors even after the massacre of thousands of their community Kshatriyas. Then how come these crooked Brahmins managed to believe that they had killed Kshatriyas for the universal benefit? What is that benefit that Brahmins have done for the Universe except leading their life without any production intellectually or materially by manipulating the most productive groups such as agricultural and professional groups such as farmers, gold smiths, weavers or leather communities historically? What was the Brahmins standpoint on merciless killings of Parashuram in their Hindutva scriptures which made believe that Parashuram had guided by Hindu Gods to eliminate the Kshatriytas for the sake of Universal benefits.

Present status of Kshatriyas in India:

Kshatriyas are the puppets in the hands of these barbarian Brahmins without any shame. Even though these uncivilized and intellectually inferior or Iranian origins based Brahmins have proudly say that they had eliminated entire Kshatriya community these shameless Kshatriyas are hardcore followers of Brahmins.

Present Status of Untouchables and Muslims:

Untouchables and Muslims are living in the shadow of fear after BJP coming to power. BJP or its terrorist outfits RSS, VHP, Bajrangdal are targeting Untouchables and Muslims to eliminate them from the Indian soil. But still some of Untouchables belonged to Hinduism are remained in the fold of Hinduism when the 99% Untouchables of south India had converted to Great Religion i.e. Christianity. Hinduism has become threat for not only knowledge creation but also humans particularly for the communities of Untouchables and Islam. Untouchables or even I can advise my Pooja-Yadavas should leave this barbarian Hindu religion to develop themselves intellectually, scientifically, educationally, socially, culturally and progressively without carrying irrational and uncivilized Hindu cultural life. My mighty Yadavas should follow great genius Professor Kancha Ilaiah or Gurram Jashuva who are converted to Christianity from the Yadav community in order to educate themselves and to save themselves from the tyranny of Brahmins.

Wednesday, 20 July 2016

VICTIMS OF HINDU SLAVERY IN INDIA


If anyone knows the history of slavery in India will be shocked to hear pathetic condition of Sudras (Agricultural sections) and Untouchables at the hands of Brahmins who migrated to India from the Central Asia. Brahmins are the foreign race who conquered indigenous sections by using various false religious sanctions such as they are the representatives of God on earth and they are the Gods on earth. They have manipulated indigenous sections with their crook and criminal mind set to rule the people without producing anything except depending on non-Brahmins. So you may be surprised to ask me how come these barbarian Hindu Brahmins had conquered the indigenous Indians and how come they are dominating the majority Hindus. First of all they have created caste system to isolate people to people in the name of purity and impurity and second they have ingrained the notion among every section of people that they are superiors among their own castes or tribal’s by accepting Brahmin as a final superior  to decide their future. Brahmin self is filled with cruel thoughts and criminal mind set to remain their hold on the majority masses in the name of Brahmin superior and Brahmin God. He insulted even God the omnipresence on earth by claiming that he is a God on earth. Brahmin has derogated characters of even God by introducing inhuman theories and practices upon majority people who never love each other but enmity. Unlike American masters over their African slaves Hindu Brahmins conquered the mind set of majority masses to believe that whatever Brahmin says is the direct order from the omnipresent or almighty God. So majority Hindus had accepted the divinity power of Brahmin with the introduction of inhuman Hindu scriptures which gave power to Brahmins. Ironically these uncivilized Hindu scriptures have written by uncivilized Brahmins 3000 years ago and followed by uneducated non-Brahmins as sheep follow the shepherd. But these barbarian Brahmins are not good shepherds unlike Jesus Christ who guided His people into right path to love and care their fellow human beings. Barbarian Brahmins have created their own Hindu Gods who guide their followers to kill outside of their community for the sake of power culturally or socially which paved way for the creation of inequalities permanently.

My own Pooja-Yadav community Sri Krishna’s example is important in guiding Arjuna to eliminate Karna even though Krishna or Rama is myth without any historical evidence for their existence. Krishna or Rama had guided their community people to kill innocent people who are not from their community background. Nowhere in the world are those so-called Gods guiding their community people to kill outside of their communities. Very interesting and pitiable that Indian Hindu Gods are such inhuman Gods to sanction their followers to kill innocent people who eat beef. Nowhere I saw that eating beef is crime for the Hindu Gods so their followers eliminate people who eat beef. In the Holy Bible all living creatures are equal and they are sanction to eat without any grading to special animal or bird. They are all equally qualified to eat. God has sanction to eat them without any discrimination. But Hindu scriptures are worshiping Cow as a holy animal like Brahmin whereas remaining animals are unholy like non-Brahmins. Non-Brahmins are following what these barbarian Brahmins are saying without any rationality or shame. There is a missing link among non-Brahmins i.e lack of questioning Brahmins and their superiority, superstitions and blind beliefs that are well established by these Ayyangars or bhats who established slavery among agriculture castes and Untouchables permanently.

I started reading Holy Bible’s Old Testament and New Testament I have never come across anything like kill your enemy for remaining your power. Perhaps, Holy Bible directed its people to love your enemy or neighbor. Where is the Biblical philosophy among Hindu Gods or their followers? I never come across any teachings of Son of God Jesus Christ who guided His people to eliminate weaker sections but indeed guided His people to love and care most vulnerable sections in the society. Nowhere in the Hindu have had scriptures guided their people to be honest or to be loved by God but guiding its people to be isolated from the humans itself to protect their purity and impurity. It has sanction caste system to protect their purity and impurity. Even converted Christians from the Brahmin or non-Brahmin castes have spoiled the spirit of Jesus Christ by carrying their age old caste practices even after conversion to Christianity. Kerala’s Syrian Christians are the best example for this grater sin against HIS wishes and philosophy. Whatever these Hindu converts of Syrian Christians are doing just against Son of God and they have to prepare for answering Him.

I have seen a white Brazilian marrying an African woman in Salvador in Brazil. I have seen an African Father or Pastor who are leading white dominated Churches in Brazil. Indeed in India I never seen a Brahmin converted Christian is attending the Church running by an Untouchable or Muslim converted Christian. Christian is such a great religion which has been reduced to be like Hindu religion by these Hindu converts. It is a grater sin that they have to answer God in Heaven after their death. These Hindu converts converted Christianity into Hindu religion with their lunatic Brahmanical practices in the Holy Church. Jesus Christ might be hanged Himself by observing these Hindu converts and their practical life like their fellow Hindu faiths holders from their same community.

Now in this 21st century of India we have a modern slavery practicing by corporate MNCs or Medical institutions against most productive groups or let me adopt what Althusier used Ideological State Apparatus through government institutions with the support of Judiciary. Judiciary is another Brahmanical Hindu institution to carry the legacy of Brahmin superiority. Indians should educate to destroy the Brahmincal slavery even in this 21st century India to establish egalitarian society. What Gunner Mirdal is used right word for the Asian Drama is right for Indian society who are playing their role as a Brahmin, Kshatriya, Vaishya, Sudra which is unethical, irrational, unscientific, barbarian in any sense. Scientific studies strongly proved that Brahmins are not Indians but migrated from the Central Asia so let us not entertain these anti-nationals who have separated our brothers and sisters in the name of caste purity and impurity for ages.

I am hoping that at least my Pooja-Yadavas will follow the footsteps of Great Genius Gurram Jashuva and Mahatma Jothibha Phule who are greatly inspired by Christian philosophy in order to challenge the Brahmanical hegemony.


Tuesday, 19 July 2016

BEWARE OF VEGETERIAN EATERS


What are the nation, nation state and nationalism in the context of Indian Hindu society? Is there any rational or civilized nationalism at all or is it all any nationalism existed in India is a doubtful. For my understanding of reading on real nationalism is very much laid in the philosophy of broader understanding of equality, liberty, freedom and fraternity to establish egalitarian state in which every minority or weaker section can enjoy his or her status without afraid of any threatening from the majority groups. But unfortunately Indian Hindu society is giving derogatory meaning to the word called nationalism since its origin of so-called national movement. Does Indian society have the ethical stamina to define the nationalism from the philosophy of western principals of minority or weaker section rights to exercise food habits, beliefs, dresses etc without threatening calls from the majority Hindu groups? Why majority Hindu groups are in a great position of lack of ethical stamina to accept the freedom of speech or freedom of writing from the minority groups such as Untouchables and Muslims? What made Hindu regime to support the violence against weaker sections Untouchables and Muslims even though UNO has declared proclamation of human rights for every human being irrespective of majority or minority and rich or poor and white or Asian. How to define nation state in the present circumstances when the Hindu regime is supporting ‘chicken’ ‘mutton’ ‘vegetarian’ eaters to kill ‘beef’ eaters. It seems that even judiciary is supporting violence against beef eaters. According to scientific studies beef is the highly nutritious food in the world. It is giving relief to many lifeless people who are suffering from grater deceases. Why can’t apex court in India proclaim judgment on beef eating without leaving it to personal beliefs? Generally law offices in the white western Christian nations come into existence in support of scientific reason and its application without looking into its citizens beliefs. How to understand when a lower court in Utter Pradesh issued an order to file an FIR against a victim family for the cause of beef eating based on the forensic reports. What is wrong with beef eating and is it against fundamental rights of India? Or beef eating is a crime? Should judiciary system determine the food habits of weaker sections what to eat or what not to eat? Are we living in the dark age of Ram Rajya or Sri Krishanas Pandava era in this twenty first century? Are we living in the fear of life threat from the majority Hindu groups who are controlling our food habits or dress habits? Who are responsible for leaving weaker sections in the hands of majority groups to die? Who gave permission to majority Hindutva groups to come and hang weaker sections for the sake of beef eating? Where is sate when the majority groups are killing, raping, maiming the weaker sections in the name of caste, religion, culture, tradition, food habits and dress code? Where are so-called progressive intellectuals when atrocities are going against Muslims and Untouchables?  What made Professor Ashish Nandi to say that traditional Hindu based RSS has the cultural intellectual arguments?  What is the line of knowledge creation among Hindu terrorist group RSS or its outfits such as BJP, VHP, Bajrang Dal except ingraining uncivilized  religious beliefs to suppress the Untouchables or women in the name of purity and impurity. What is wrong if any mighty Yadav come forward to issue moral orders to ban eating sheep or goat of non-Yadavas for the sake of his love towards sheep or goat with which that Yadav is very much associated right from his or her childhood days unlike a Hindu Brahmin who never associate with any productive things except depending on unproductive activities such as temples or spreading superstitions and blind beliefs in the name of karma to carry his legacy of superiority of Brahmin self. What will happen entire mighty Yadav community ban the sheep eating of non-Yadavas? What if farmers issue an order to ban eating his or her rice for the sake of his or her love towards his crops? What if a chicken rendering people issue a threat to ban the chicken eating among rice eaters or mutton eaters or beef or pork eaters? What will happen if Chamars ban the shoe wearing of non-Chamars for the sake of their love towards skin of the cow or buffalo? What will happen if the white western Christians ban the entry of Hindus into their countries for the sake of conflict religious beliefs and superstitions or blind beliefs of Hindus that their countries should not get spoiled like irrational Hindu society? What will happen if Western educational institutions ban the students from the non-knowledge societies such as Asia or subcontinent for getting knowledge? Why Indian Hindu government is has lack of intellectuals to define what fundamental right is or what is not? Why can’t majority Hindus failed to understand meaning of Constitutionalism and its philosophy of equality, liberty, freedom and fraternity. What made Hindus to be inferiors in terms of knowledge creation which can be benefited by the universal human being despite of their 6000 years of domination in subcontinent? What made majority Hindus scare of Untouchables or Muslims. Why is Hindu society have failed to produce intellectuals but liars, manipulators, fraud, dishonest, ethically week, morally down, sadhus, sanyasis, etc . I am reminding what a great genius Professor Aloysius said about this uncivilized people in his ground breaking work NATIONALISM WITHOUT A NATION IN INDIA. Majority identities should create a space for intellectual discussions, debate, thought sharing, opinion sharing through vast reading of social sciences with rational approach. Religious tolerance is what Father of Indian Constitution Dr B R Ambedkar said in his classical piece Indian Constitution. When will Hindus follow this great genius who rebelled against uncivilized Hindu religion and its irrational practices?  You can kill progressive minds like us but you can’t kill spirit of progressivism. If billions of irrational Hindus rise to kill progressive minds ineed spirit will not die. I may get killed by Hindutva groups but my spirit will not die. When India would became nation state from the definition of western nationalism. When will Hindus learn to respect minorities and Untouchables for their food habits? Or Should Ambedakr born again from his tomb to teach Hindus what is rationality what is not like Jesus Christ who sacrificed Himself on Cross for the sake of our sins? You can’t focus on national interest without cleaning your kitchen which is filled with human shit. What Untouchables and Muslims want is exercising their freedom of food habits so weaker sections need to live without fear but not national interest. When there is no guarantee of life in your own kitchen then where will you focus on national interests? You may manipulate white western Christian society by sending cheap labout to those countries to serve white people but truth is thicker than blood so soon weaker sections will capture political power through the constitutional means as their Master Ambedakr said, political power is the master key to abolish at lease few hierarchies or inequalities if not religiously well established caste system. What Nicolas Dirks said in his master piece Castes of mind? As long as Indian Hindu society carry castes of mind they won’t became intellectuals or they won’t allow their neighbors with their uncivilized and irrational thoughts and actions. Hindu Brahmins have spoiled the USA, Great Britain, and Australia, Canada or other European countries with their migration to those countries 100 years back by introducing Yoga or mediation. ISCON is another Hindu organization who is converting whites to this uncivilized religion. If you look the knowledge creation of above countries where Hindus are majority knowledge is decreasing year by year. Africa or Middle East countries will be dominating in coming decades in terms of knowledge creation