Wednesday 3 November 2021

Once, Manfred Nowak, the former United Nations Special Rapporteur on Torture from 2004 to 2010, replied to my email saying that binary (mainstream genders) should represent non-binary (LGBTQ) groups. He even gave me a nonsensical example of how children can represent themselves if adults can not. How come a male and a female represent the LGBTQ community? How come a Hindu represents the Untouchable? How come a Muslim represents Yazidis? How come a male represents a female? How come men represent women? Why do male intellectuals represent females in knowledge production and policymaking? Why do male intellectuals represent females in knowledge production and policymaking? How come a non-disabled person represents the disabled? How come mainstream groups represent subaltern groups? How come subaltern groups represent sub-subaltern groups? The United Nations has failed to eradicate obnoxious practices such as casteism, untouchability, racism, and violence in third-world societies because they recruit from mainstream castes, religions, ethnic groups, religions, cultures, traditions, and genders. Sorry, we don't need your representation. We can represent ourselves. There is a historical bias in your representation. We are done with your politics of representing marginalized sections. 


 Once, Manfred Nowak, the former United Nations Special Rapporteur on Torture from 2004 to 2010, replied to my email saying that binary (mainstream genders) should represent non-binary (LGBTQ) groups. He even gave me a nonsensical example of how children can represent themselves if adults can not. How come a male and a female represent the LGBTQ community? How come a Hindu represents the Untouchable? How come a Muslim represents Yazidis? How come a male represents a female? How come men represent women? Why do male intellectuals represent females in knowledge production and policymaking? Why do male intellectuals represent females in knowledge production and policymaking? How come a non-disabled person represents the disabled? How come mainstream groups represent subaltern groups? How come subaltern groups represent sub-subaltern groups? The United Nations has failed to eradicate obnoxious practices such as casteism, untouchability, racism, and violence in third-world societies because they recruit from mainstream castes, religions, ethnic groups, religions, cultures, traditions, and genders.

Sorry, we don't need your representation. We can represent ourselves. There is a historical bias in your representation. We are done with your politics of representing marginalized sections. 

No comments:

Post a Comment